When Jonathan was developing photos in the school's darkroom, Nicole came in and greeted him. Nicole managed to get a brief look at the photos before Jonathan quickly grabbed them and left.
Nicole aided Steve, Carol, and Tommy in vandalizing the Hawk. She looked on as Nancy confronted Steve, and watched the fight between Steve and Jonathan. When the police arrived, she ran away with her friends as Jonathan was arrested. However, by the time Steve, Tommy and Carol had arrived at the gas station, Nicole had left their company.