I say Max she is stronger faster and she was able to escape Vecna and if Nancy ain't got no weapon she is down right screwed

I say Nancy because I think she has more experience in fighting to take on Max

Sorry Max

Max was able to escape Vecna because she was able to become mentally strong, I don't think that would help a lot if we're talking about a fistfight.

Nancy for sure

Nancy is a valkyrie

@Rachelmayfield011 nancy is powerful when she has access to her guns but I think she would lose a fist fight bc of how athletic Max is and how skinny Nancy is

Nancy, she literally pointed a gun at Steve in the first season.

Nancy can literally use a gun

Nancy has a goddamn shotgun.

How the heck do you guys think Nancy freaking Wheeler would win?!! Nancy is good with a gun but assuming this is a had-to-hand fight Nancy would hardly do anything, and can we talk about that slap in season 1, to Steve that has to be the worst slap I have ever seen! But Max has a much higher endurance level than Nancy, and I don’t think Nancy is fast enough to even be able to run away from Vecna!

Exactly! Max is athletic and Nancy is skinny af!