oh.

It's a sock or a Playboy magazine because Erica says "cowboy"

WHAT

Maybe like some playboy magazine like @Goesbar97 said

Probably a secret that was either something for Max or something that he had when he was young that he is embrassed of

Erica literally makes the biggest deal out of everything. I’ve been trying to convince people for months that it’s probably just a love letter to Max and she calls it “gross” because she hates anything to do with love 😂

Lucas the on the Line confirmed it was a p—n magazine.

WHAT

I assume sthat

My theory is A LOT weirder when I say weirder I mean REALLY REALLY REALLY GROSS. trust me and I'm listening to running up that hill right now